PVA
The glossary

A term worth knowing

Peer review

A peer review is an independent assessment of a project's design, assumptions, documents, or decisions by a qualified reviewer who is not the author of the work being examined. The scope can range from focused review of a particular discipline or question to a broader review of coordination, cost, schedule, and delivery risks. A peer review is not automatically a formal code review, certification, or replacement for the duties of the design professionals. Its value depends on a clear question, relevant expertise, access to current information, and a defined response process.

Context

Why it matters

A fresh perspective can identify overlooked assumptions, unclear requirements, coordination gaps, or opportunities for the owner to make a better-informed decision. Independent feedback is most useful when it arrives early enough for the team to evaluate and respond.

The review should support, not confuse, accountability. Owners need to know which findings are observations or questions, who is responsible for technical confirmation, and how accepted or rejected recommendations will be documented.

At the table

Questions for the owner

  • 01What decision or risk is the review intended to address, and what material is current enough to answer it? Define boundaries, exclusions, timing, and intended users so the reviewer focuses on the owner's real question.
  • 02Does the reviewer have experience appropriate to the subject and independence from the work under review? Confirm qualifications and any conflicts, and identify where licensed professional judgment or specialist analysis is required.
  • 03How will findings be prioritized, answered, and tracked to closure? Ask the project team to assign a responsible responder, record the disposition and basis, and identify any recommendations requiring design revisions, cost review, or owner approval.
Confidential fit discussionRequest a project review