PVA
All insights

Contracts & Bidding Owner-side insight

How to Review a GMP Before You Sign It: An Owner's Guide

A practical owner-side review connects the GMP amount to the documents, responsibilities, assumptions, and decisions that will govern construction.

By Sam CastelanPublished Updated 8 min read

Establish exactly what the GMP covers

A guaranteed maximum price is not a complete description of the work. It is a commercial commitment built from a set of documents, assumptions, and procedures. Before judging whether the amount fits the project, identify the drawings, specifications, addenda, estimate, schedule, proposal, and contract exhibits that form its basis. Ask the contractor to identify the version and date of every document used to prepare the price.

Check that the estimate and contract refer to the same design set. A proposal may refer to drawings that have since changed, or a specification may describe an item absent from the estimate. Record each discrepancy rather than assuming the latest file automatically governs. Confirm with the project team which documents control if they conflict, and ask counsel to review that language.

Compare the stated scope with the owner’s program and current design. Trace major building systems and packages from design information to estimate line and then to contract exhibit. Look for descriptions such as “by others,” “as required,” or “to be confirmed.” These phrases may signal a scope boundary, not an included obligation. Ask who performs, purchases, coordinates, tests, and accepts the item.

For an owner-side GMP review, organize the questions into scope, price basis, schedule, and contract administration. This makes it easier to distinguish an unresolved design choice from an omission in the estimate or a term that needs legal review.

Separate allowances from contingency

An allowance is generally a placeholder for an identified item whose final selection, quantity, or price is not settled. It should not be a vague bucket for unrelated unknown work. For every allowance, ask what the amount includes: product, quantity, installation, delivery, taxes, support, controls, and associated work. The specific list depends on the project, so compare it with the contract documents rather than applying a generic checklist mechanically.

Then identify the decision that will replace the allowance. Who selects the item? Who reviews its technical suitability? When must the choice be made to protect procurement and schedule? What evidence will support the reconciliation between the allowance and final cost? Have the team record the original basis, the decision owner, the required date, and the process for documenting any adjustment.

Contingency is different. It may be intended to address a defined category of uncertainty, but the agreement needs to say whose contingency it is and how it can be used. Ask who controls authorization, what backup is required, whether notice is required before a commitment, how the owner sees the remaining balance, and what happens to unused funds. Do not assume a contractor-held contingency and an owner reserve are interchangeable.

Keep each reserve visible in the cost report. A clear report separates committed scope, allowances awaiting reconciliation, contingency, owner-directed changes, and other project reserves. Ask the contractor to demonstrate how these categories flow through monthly reporting and final accounting. Review the mechanism with counsel and the project’s cost professionals.

Review exclusions and qualifications as scope

Exclusions state what the proposed price does not include. Qualifications state the conditions or assumptions under which the contractor or a trade priced its work. Both can materially change the apparent coverage of the GMP. Read each line alongside the design, estimate, owner budget, and responsibility matrix.

For every exclusion, determine whether the work is a planned owner purchase, a separate contract, a utility or authority responsibility, or a scope gap that still needs an answer. Name the party responsible for procurement and installation, identify interfaces, and show where the funding is carried. If the work appears elsewhere in the budget, verify that it has not been counted twice. If no one owns it, do not let the issue remain hidden under a broad allowance.

For qualifications, ask whether the condition limits quantities, access, working hours, site preparation, protection, testing, warranty, or coordination. Compare the qualification with the design and site information available to the bidder. If it depends on an assumption, identify how the team will verify that assumption and what happens if it proves incorrect.

Use a written register with the item, source document, responsible party, resolution, schedule connection, and budget location. Have the contractor and design team respond to the same register. Close agreed clarifications into the estimate and contract exhibits before execution rather than relying on meeting recollection.

Understand escalation and procurement exposure

An escalation provision can address price movement during a defined period, but its effect depends on the contract language and procurement facts. Locate the clause and identify which materials or packages it covers, the time period, the trigger, the calculation method, required supporting records, notice requirements, and any limits or exclusions. Do not treat a general statement about market conditions as a complete adjustment formula.

Compare the provision with current trade quotations and procurement status. Ask which quotes are firm, which expire, what quantities they cover, whether taxes and freight are included, and whether any deposits or early-release commitments are assumed. Confirm who can authorize a purchase and how the owner will receive notice of an approaching expiration. Tie these dates to the design and owner decision schedule.

If the price can change after signing, make the change mechanism understandable before signing. The owner should be able to follow the evidence from quote or invoice through review, authorization, and cost report. Ask counsel to assess enforceability and consistency with the rest of the agreement. Ask the estimator or construction advisor to examine whether the pricing basis and documentation are complete.

An owner-side construction contract review can help examine the agreement’s scope, pricing terms, and change procedures alongside the GMP.

Inspect general conditions and schedule assumptions

General conditions cover project-level requirements that support construction rather than a single trade installation. Review the staffing, site supervision, temporary facilities, access, safety administration, utilities, cleanup, protection, equipment, and other listed items against the proposed schedule and project logistics. The relevant categories vary by project; the task is to test whether the description and duration fit the actual plan.

Ask which positions and resources are included, when they are expected on site, and what schedule assumptions support them. Confirm whether the amount changes if the project duration changes, and how extensions, owner-caused delay, weather, or sequencing changes are treated. Review whether temporary work and services are included, assigned to another party, or excluded. These details often sit outside the trade bid comparisons but still affect the owner’s overall exposure.

Read general conditions together with milestones, work hours, phasing, access restrictions, permits, inspections, and owner-furnished items. Ask the contractor to identify the decisions or approvals needed to maintain the proposed sequence. Compare the schedule basis with the design team’s remaining work and procurement requirements. Counsel should review the contractual remedies and notice rules; the owner’s advisor should make sure the cost and schedule assumptions are visible.

Clarify savings and change rules

If the contract provides for shared savings, read the definition before treating a projected underrun as owner savings. Determine the baseline against which savings are measured, which scope changes are included, how allowances and contingency are reconciled, what costs are deducted, who verifies the calculation, and when the accounting occurs. Ask whether scope reduction, substitutions, procurement credits, and buyout results are treated consistently. Do not accept an undefined reference to “savings” as a substitute for a clear process.

The agreement should also explain how a proposed change is priced and approved. Ask what backup is required for added work and credits, how labor and material quantities are demonstrated, how schedule effects are documented, and who may authorize a change. Establish that the owner’s team has time to review a request before work proceeds except where the agreement provides a different procedure for urgent conditions. Discuss the full process with counsel.

PVA’s owner checklist can help organize documents, decisions, and open questions before bid or contract review. For related bid comparisons, use the bid-leveling service to make coverage and qualifications easier to compare.

Build a decision-ready review record

Do not send a long comment log without priorities. For each open item, state the document reference, what is unclear, who must answer, what decision is needed, and whether it affects scope, budget, schedule, procurement, or contract language. Mark whether the item is a clarification, an owner selection, a potential scope gap, or a point for counsel.

Ask the contractor and design professionals to respond against the same current document set. Update the estimate and exhibits when a resolution changes the price basis. Keep a record of accepted clarifications and the versions reviewed. Before execution, review the final package as a whole: proposal, estimate, scope exhibits, schedule, allowances, contingency terms, exclusions, qualifications, and change procedures must describe a coherent arrangement.

A relevant pre-PVA team case illustrates why agreements deserve direct review. On a large-scale mixed-use project in the San Francisco Bay Area, team members negotiated consultant and contractor agreements. The team’s estimates described proposed agreements at about $29 million and negotiated agreements at about $24.5 million, with estimated savings of about $4.5 million. These are team estimates, not a forecast or guarantee for another project. See the approved project samples for the case context.

Frequently asked questions

Is a GMP the same as a fixed final cost?

Not automatically. The agreement may contain allowances, exclusions, qualifications, owner decisions, escalation provisions, or change procedures that affect the final amount. Read the contract’s price adjustment terms and scope exhibits with qualified legal and cost professionals.

Should an owner review the GMP before signing?

Yes. Reviewing the basis before execution gives the parties a chance to clarify scope, responsibility, pricing assumptions, and decisions while the agreement is being finalized. It does not replace legal advice or technical review.

What should I send for a GMP review?

Provide the current proposal, draft agreement, estimate, drawings, specifications, schedule, trade coverage, allowance and contingency detail, exclusions, qualifications, and open decision log. Identify the signing date and the questions that need resolution first.

About the author

Sam Castelan

Chief Consultancy Officer (Senior Architect, Master Planner, MBA, MPL, MPA)

Brings development, master planning, and value engineering experience.

Meet the PVA team

Keep reading

A second set of eyes

Your next project decision deserves a closer look.

Scope and commercial terms are agreed in writing.

Request a project review
Confidential fit discussionRequest a project review