PVA

Owner-side project advisory

GMP Review for Owners and Developers

A guaranteed maximum price is only as useful as the scope, assumptions, exclusions, and contract terms behind it. Before signing, owners and developers need to understand what is included, what remains unresolved, and how changes will be handled. Project Value Advisors helps owners review that picture alongside their project professionals.

DevelopersOwnersLandownersInvestorsLenders

Read the GMP as a set of connected documents

A GMP proposal commonly draws on a contract, exhibits, drawings, specifications, estimate, schedule, allowances, alternates, and a list of qualifications. The owner should know which documents control, how conflicts are resolved, and which design information the number assumes. A review starts by assembling the current version of each item and checking that the references point to the same scope.

A total alone cannot tell you whether the package covers the intended project. Compare the proposal against the owner’s program and the current design. Look for incomplete scopes, duplicated scope, temporary work, site requirements, testing, closeout, and work assigned to “others.” Then confirm which party is responsible for those items and whether they appear elsewhere in the budget.

Test allowances and contingency against the open work

Allowances and contingencies address uncertainty differently. An allowance may stand in for a defined purchase or scope that is not yet selected or priced. Contingency may be held against a category of unknowns under agreed rules. The owner needs to know the amount, basis, approval process, documentation, and treatment of unused funds for each line. Those terms are contract-specific and should be reviewed with counsel.

Tie every placeholder back to an unresolved decision. Ask what quantity or specification it assumes, when pricing will be confirmed, who can authorize a draw, and how the owner will receive notice. A line without an owner, trigger, or closeout path can obscure rather than control exposure. A clear log turns open items into assignable work.

  • Identify the assumed scope and quantity.
  • Record the responsible party and date for confirmation.
  • Understand documentation, approval, reconciliation, and closeout.

Compare bid coverage, not just trade totals

The estimate should connect trade proposals to the scope they price. Check major packages for exclusions, qualifications, alternates, unit rates, escalation, bonds, insurance, and schedule assumptions. Review whether quotes are current and whether scope gaps between packages have an identified owner. If a trade bid excludes coordination or certain materials, determine where that work appears in the contract.

Scope alignment matters even when the contractor is not competitively bidding each package. Owners can ask for a clear description of procurement status, quote coverage, and the method used to carry each package. A transparent estimate helps the team make choices before buyout and track changes after award.

Clarify change, schedule, and decision rules

The maximum price does not answer every question about change. Review the process for owner-directed changes, design development, differing assumptions, allowances, unused contingency, and any cost savings proposal. Confirm how the contract distinguishes an included obligation from extra work and how the parties will document a time or cost effect. Get legal advice on the final contract language.

Schedule assumptions also affect price. Check milestones, long-lead decisions, owner-furnished items, permit dependencies, working hours, and the consequences of delayed information. A schedule that depends on selections or approvals should assign those dates and responsibilities. A review should make the risk visible without promising that every delay or cost can be predicted.

An owner-side review before signature

PVA can organize the estimate, drawings, bid coverage, and proposed terms into a decision-focused review. We flag inconsistencies, questions, and missing owner decisions for discussion with the contractor and the project’s design and legal professionals. We do not give legal advice, certify the GMP, or replace a licensed cost estimator or project architect.

The timing is important. A review before execution gives the owner a better chance to resolve unclear scope while the project team is still negotiating its baseline. After execution, the same issue may follow a contractual change process instead. Send the current package and identify the signing date or open question so the review can focus on the decisions that matter now.

What we typically look at in the first 30 days

We typically start with the current drawings, project budget or estimate, relevant bids or agreements, the project schedule, and the decision you need to make. We compare scope and assumptions, identify information gaps, and organize owner-side questions for the responsible project professionals. The exact review depends on your project stage and the materials available. We do not promise a result from an initial document review.

Team member-led project before PVA · Estimated outcome

Large-Scale Mixed-Use · San Francisco Bay Area, CA

On a large master-planned development, consultant and contractor agreements with major national firms were reviewed and negotiated directly.

Team members negotiated the proposed agreements within 90 days, comparing proposed terms against the revised contract amounts.

The negotiated amounts represented estimated savings of about $4.5M, roughly 15%, compared with the original proposals.

Read the approved project examples

Start with a clear project picture

Use the project check to map contract timing, bid status, and the questions to resolve before signature.

Try the project check

Frequently asked questions

What should an owner check in a GMP proposal?

Start with document alignment, scope inclusions and exclusions, allowances, contingency rules, bid coverage, schedule assumptions, escalation, change processes, and responsibility for work assigned to others.

Does a guaranteed maximum price mean the owner has no further cost exposure?

Not necessarily. The contract’s scope, assumptions, change provisions, allowances, and exclusions define the parties’ obligations. Have project counsel review the proposed agreement.

When should a GMP be reviewed?

Before signing, when the supporting drawings, estimate, bid coverage, and terms are available. If information remains open, record how it will be confirmed and handled.

Can PVA negotiate the contract for the owner?

PVA can help the owner identify commercial questions, compare options, and prepare for discussions. The owner and its counsel make contract decisions and provide legal advice.

Request a project review

Share the decision, budget question, bid package, or site issue you are working through. We will review your request and reach out.

Request a project review

Scope and commercial terms are agreed in writing.

Confidential fit discussionRequest a project review