PVA
All insights

Development & Feasibility Owner-side insight

When Your Pro Forma Stops Working: 7 Levers to Check Before You Walk Away

A stalled pro forma is a signal to find the broken assumption. Review seven practical levers before abandoning a development plan.

By Ivan DuschatzkyPublished Updated 8 min read

Find the assumption that changed

When a development pro forma stops working, ownership is often under pressure to make a fast decision: add capital, revise the plan, delay, sell, or walk away. Before choosing, identify what changed and whether the current model still describes the project the team can deliver. A model can become unreliable because its design, cost, schedule, revenue, or approval assumptions no longer line up.

Start with the version that was used for the last meaningful decision and the most current project information. Ask the finance lead to identify which assumptions moved, when they changed, and which source documents support the updated inputs. Reconcile the latest design, estimate, bids, schedule, approval status, and operating assumptions. Keep the original and revised assumptions visible rather than overwriting the record.

As an owner-side advisor, I do not start by promising a target return or telling ownership to cut scope. I organize the questions that can still be tested. The following are exactly seven conceptual levers: unit mix, efficiency ratio, amenities consolidation, entitlements, procurement, financing structure, and phasing. Each depends on project facts and professional review. None is a guaranteed fix.

The seven levers to test

1. Unit mix

Ask whether the planned mix still matches the market and operating strategy that underpin the revenue assumptions. A shift among unit types can affect achievable rents or sales, unit area, common circulation, parking demand, building systems, and construction scope. The model should not treat a revised mix as a revenue improvement until the relevant market and operating assumptions are supported.

Have the design and finance teams compare the current plan with viable alternatives using consistent definitions. Ask what each option changes in net rentable or sellable area, count, amenity demand, and construction documents. Confirm who is responsible for validating market conclusions. The owner should know whether an apparent improvement comes from a supported program change or only from a spreadsheet input.

2. Efficiency ratio

Review how much of the designed area is usable for the project’s intended purpose and how the model defines that relationship. Gross area, rentable area, sellable area, circulation, service areas, cores, and shared space must be described consistently. A mismatch in definitions can make a comparison look better or worse without changing the actual building.

Ask the architect and cost professional to identify areas that may be inefficient and explain which design options can be studied. Check how a change affects structure, circulation, building systems, accessibility, code, and function. Do not assume that removing area creates value: the project may need that space for safe circulation, service, operations, or the expected user experience. Technical conclusions belong to the responsible licensed professionals.

3. Amenities consolidation

Consider whether amenities and support functions can be organized more efficiently while preserving the intended resident or user experience. Separate buildings or dispersed spaces may carry their own structure, foundations, envelope, utilities, and circulation. Consolidation may change those costs, but it can also affect operations, access, capacity, and the identity of the finished property.

The North Port multifamily case provides a specific team-led example from before PVA was formed. The approved case describes a 50-unit project with team-estimated cost of about $18M against team-estimated completed value of about $19M. Team members standardized units into modular components and redesigned the building around them. Moving the gym, leasing office, and amenities into the main building avoided about $1.5M in standalone structures, according to team estimates, and rentable storage was added. Team estimates report that cost fell by about $5.5M, roughly 30%, to about $12.5M while completed value remained about $19M.

These are team estimates for a pre-PVA case, not guaranteed savings or a forecast. The case shows why an owner should examine where support spaces sit and what it takes to build and operate them. Review the approved project samples for the full context and estimates.

4. Entitlements

Check whether the current model depends on approvals, interpretations, or development rights that have not been confirmed. Entitlement status can affect what program the team may pursue, what studies remain, and when design, financing, or procurement can advance. Ask the land use and design professionals to distinguish approvals already obtained from applications, assumptions, conditions, and unresolved matters.

Do not put an unconfirmed approval into the base case as though it were settled. Identify the responsible professional, authority, next submittal, and decision dependency. Ask how the pro forma changes if the current assumption takes longer, requires a revision, or is not granted. The owner’s counsel and licensed consultants should advise on legal and technical matters; an owner-side review can help keep those dependencies visible in the investment discussion.

5. Procurement

If a current estimate is driving the problem, determine whether it reflects defined scope and current market input. Compare bids and estimates by inclusions, exclusions, allowances, alternates, schedule assumptions, quantities, and package interfaces. A proposal that appears lower may leave work unpriced or transfer risk to the owner. A high estimate may include scope, contingency, or qualifications that are not comparable with the other inputs.

Ask the construction team to identify what can be competitively procured, what needs clarification, and what is not ready to price. Consider whether packages, bidder information, sequence, or contract terms are affecting the response. Do not book a possible bid reduction as a confirmed improvement before scope is reconciled and the owner understands the resulting risk. PVA’s procurement advisory helps owners examine bid coverage and contract decisions alongside their project team.

6. Financing structure

Revisit the financing assumptions with the actual capital providers and the owner’s financial and legal advisors. Sources, timing, covenants, conditions, and the availability of capital can affect whether an otherwise plausible development plan can proceed. A model should show which assumptions are confirmed, which are under discussion, and what documents or milestones remain necessary.

Ask whether a changed project scope or schedule affects lender requirements, equity timing, draw assumptions, or the owner’s ability to fund contingencies. Make sure the project team is not using an older financing assumption to justify a current design decision. PVA does not arrange financing or provide legal or accounting advice. The owner’s lender, counsel, and financial advisors must confirm the terms and implications.

7. Phasing

Examine whether the project can be sequenced differently without undermining its operation, approvals, construction logic, or financing. Phasing can change when costs are incurred and when portions of the asset become usable, but it may also introduce temporary conditions, duplicated work, remobilization, or dependencies between stages. It is not automatically a way to make a weak project viable.

Ask the architect, contractor, operator, and finance team to identify the boundaries and prerequisites for each phase. Confirm whether utilities, access, life safety, shared amenities, site work, and turnover can function as proposed. Then update the model with the costs, timing, and revenue assumptions that the team can support. Distinguish a real sequence alternative from a simple delay in the spreadsheet.

Bring the options back to one decision

After reviewing the seven levers, have the project team assemble a concise decision record. For each option, state the assumption being tested, the evidence available, the professional responsible for validation, what the alternative preserves, what it changes, and what remains uncertain. Compare each option using the same current project baseline; otherwise, a promising result may reflect inconsistent inputs rather than a better plan.

Keep an explicit line between a potential benefit and an adopted assumption. An owner may decide to commission more design, seek updated pricing, confirm an entitlement path, or return to lenders with a revised package. The pro forma should be updated only when its inputs have a documented basis and the appropriate party has confirmed them. Ask the finance lead to note the source and date of significant assumptions so the next decision can be traced.

This is the purpose of a focused pro forma review: reconnect design, cost, schedule, revenue, and capital assumptions to the actual project. Depending on the concern, an owner may also need a development feasibility study to test site and program assumptions or an owner representation review to coordinate outstanding decisions. Advisory review complements, and does not replace, licensed design professionals, contractors, counsel, or financial advisors.

The North Port case is useful because it links program standardization, amenity placement, and competitive bidding to the project’s economics. Its team-estimated outcomes belong to that project alone. Apply the method, not the figures: verify the present condition, ask which assumptions can still be influenced, and direct each question to the person qualified to answer it.

Frequently asked questions

Should I walk away when the current pro forma no longer works?

Not before confirming which assumptions changed and whether any remain open to responsible revision. Compare supported options with the current project baseline, and discuss capital and legal implications with the appropriate advisors before making an ownership decision.

Are the North Port case estimates a benchmark for my project?

No. They describe one team-led project completed before PVA was formed. The approved project samples identify those figures as estimates; they are context for the review process, not a promised result for another property.

Who should validate revised pro forma assumptions?

The responsible professionals should validate their respective inputs: design and engineering assumptions with the licensed project team, pricing and scope with cost and construction professionals, financing terms with lenders and financial advisors, and legal matters with counsel. Ownership decides which supported alternative to pursue.

About the author

Ivan Duschatzky

Co-Founder & Managing Partner

Leads client relationships and brings a national construction leadership network.

Meet the PVA team

Keep reading

A second set of eyes

Your next project decision deserves a closer look.

Scope and commercial terms are agreed in writing.

Request a project review
Confidential fit discussionRequest a project review