PVA

Owner-side project advisory

When the Pro Forma Stops Working

When the pro forma no longer supports the original plan, ownership needs to find which inputs changed and which can still be tested. Project Value Advisors helps developers and investors connect the model to design, costs, approvals, and delivery assumptions so the next decision uses a clear project basis.

DevelopersOwnersLandownersInvestorsLenders

Trace each important input to its source

Start with the version date, model purpose, and decision it is intended to support. Identify which inputs come from signed documents, consultant estimates, market assumptions, preliminary planning, or internal judgment. A model is only useful if the team can tell the difference between a confirmed commitment and an assumption that remains open.

Reconcile program, unit or area counts, phasing, construction budget, contingency, financing, timing, and operating assumptions to the latest project information. Check that the sources use consistent dates and scope. A mix of old drawings, current pricing, and optimistic approval timing can make a model appear stable while the project basis has changed.

  • Label every material assumption and its source.
  • Update the model against current drawings and commitments.
  • Keep historical versions so the direction of change is visible.

Find where the economics moved

Compare the current model with the prior approved version by input, not just by bottom-line return. Did the program change? Did contractor proposals include a different scope? Are allowances, fees, site work, utilities, or schedule carried on a different basis? Did a financing assumption or sale strategy change? A bridge between model versions helps reveal where the decision moved.

Then ask whether the movement is temporary, documented, or a new baseline. Pending approvals, incomplete design, unpriced packages, and unresolved contract terms can all create different kinds of uncertainty. Treat them separately and avoid adding a general cushion that hides the source of a risk.

Test alternatives that match the owner’s strategy

The model can compare a limited set of scenarios tied to real choices. Options might involve phasing, unit mix, building configuration, amenities, specifications, procurement timing, or site utilization. For each one, state what must change and which design, approval, operating, and schedule questions need validation before the model relies on it.

Run sensitivity cases around assumptions that have not been verified. This can show where a plan becomes sensitive to cost, timing, lease-up, or financing. It does not make those outcomes predictable. Investors and owners should distinguish analysis prepared to explore an option from an approved business plan, underwriting conclusion, or representation to a lender.

Keep the development team and model aligned

A pro forma should have named assumptions and owners. The architect confirms program and area inputs, the cost professional explains estimate scope and date, the contractor addresses proposal coverage, and the finance team sets the agreed model treatment. The owner retains responsibility for the investment decision. This discipline reduces the chance that different workstreams use inconsistent versions.

Maintain a concise change log for each update: input, old basis, new basis, source, reviewer, and decision status. Flag changes that depend on further diligence rather than placing them in the base case without explanation. Schedule review points when the project reaches bid, approval, financing, or contract milestones so the model can be refreshed from current information.

Independent review and next steps

PVA reviews the model alongside available project documents to identify gaps between financial assumptions and the project as designed, priced, and approved. The work is scoped to the owner’s question and can help prioritize follow-up with design, cost, legal, finance, or market professionals. PVA does not provide investment advice, an appraisal, an audit, or a guarantee of project performance.

A first review can focus on the changes since the last viable plan, the commitments already made, and the information required for the next investment decision. Bring the current model, its prior version if available, recent estimate or proposals, and a short description of the concern. Clear inputs make it easier to decide what should be tested next.

What we typically look at in the first 30 days

We typically start with the current drawings, project budget or estimate, relevant bids or agreements, the project schedule, and the decision you need to make. We compare scope and assumptions, identify information gaps, and organize owner-side questions for the responsible project professionals. The exact review depends on your project stage and the materials available. We do not promise a result from an initial document review.

Team member-led project before PVA · Estimated outcome

Multifamily · North Port, FL

A 50-unit project had an estimated cost of about $18M against a completed value of about $19M and was not financially viable as planned.

Team members standardized units into modular components and helped redesign the building around them. Moving the gym, leasing office, and amenities into the main building avoided about $1.5M in standalone structures; rentable storage was added. They then led bidding and negotiation, bringing proposals about 20% below the originals.

Estimated cost fell by about $5.5M, roughly 30%, with completed value unchanged.

Read the approved project examples

Start with a clear project picture

Use the project check to describe the gap between your development assumptions and the current project position.

Try the project check

Frequently asked questions

What does a development pro forma review check?

It compares model inputs with the current program, design, budget, schedule, approvals, financing assumptions, and available market information. The review also records which assumptions remain unverified.

Can a pro forma review determine whether to invest?

It can clarify assumptions and scenarios, but the investment decision belongs to the owner and its advisers. A review is not an appraisal, legal opinion, or assurance of returns.

What should I provide for an initial review?

The current pro forma, a prior version if available, the latest estimate or contractor proposals, and a short description of the decision or concern.

Should unapproved alternatives be put in the base case?

Keep them identified as scenarios until the owner has enough design, approval, pricing, or operating information to decide whether they belong in the plan.

Request a project review

Share the decision, budget question, bid package, or site issue you are working through. We will review your request and reach out.

Request a project review

Scope and commercial terms are agreed in writing.

Keep exploring

Request a project review Scope and commercial terms are agreed in writing.
Confidential fit discussionRequest a project review